Taxing residential properties: Is it time to pull the lever?
31 January 2021
Trying to slow the rapid increase in house prices may involve a whole suite of policy measures, says Professor Craig Elliffe.

A recent New Zealand Herald article trumpeted the news that house prices will rise by 13 to 16% over the next few months.
Most people I have spoken to express disbelief that there is such a disconnection between these asset values, the ratio of average income to average property prices, and the comparative cost of residential property in other jurisdictions.
I believe that rapidly growing house prices are a problem for four reasons.
• It generates inequality of a relatively high level within our society. This inequality results in different opportunities for people in the circles in which they mix, the education they receive, the investment opportunities offered to them, and the experience they receive in terms of law and order and personal security.
• It creates an intergenerational unfairness. Children cannot afford deposits or borrowing without parental help, yet those same parents had little problems finding sufficient funds to purchase their properties. It also could be noted that some of these parents enjoyed free tertiary education when they were young and now a universal pension.
• Except for real estate agents and the banks, the country doesn't become a more productive or wealthy society because of these inflated prices.
• Increased indebtedness associated with such stretched pricing results in greater risk and fragility in the economy. Interest rates are at historic lows. The Government has itself borrowed and pumped money into a Covid-19-sized economic hole. An increase in interest rates will cause considerable distress in the private and public sectors, but in the private sector in particular.
Trying to slow the rapid increase in house prices may involve a whole suite of policy measures. Urban intensification, imposing restrictions on borrowings, reducing construction costs and increasing land supply has been considered and sometimes adopted. My view is that pulling the tax lever is worth considering again.
Susan St John has rightly raised the logic of using the riskfree return method (RFRM) as a sensible alternative. The Government's Tax Working Group in 2018-19 carefully considered RFRM as an alternative to a comprehensive capital gains tax.
In the end, the majority (of eight members) thought that the best way to future-proof a tax system that was going to encounter problems with ageing demographics, reduced labour income and increasing inequality was a comprehensive capital gains tax.
The minority (three members) in essence thought the costs of a CGT outweighed the benefits. All 11 members of the tax working group agreed that residential property investment required additional taxation.
Papers prepared for the Tax Working Group discussion in October 2018 disclosed that at a risk-free return rate of 3.5%, the estimated revenue from introducing an RFRM (in addition to the existing rules such as the bright-line provisions) would be about $1 billion in year one. After 10 years, by 2031, this would increase to $2 billion a year. Some landlords would pay less tax (if they had meagre interest costs and high rental returns), but there would be extra deemed income across the sector.
Some of the objections to RFRM remain valid (such as singling out an asset class and the possibility of inadequate cash flows to fund the tax). Still, numerous attractions include comparative ease of calculation and certainty of income stream for the Government.
Consequently, the tax lever is likely to tax a currently undertaxed asset class more adequately and act as a curb to burgeoning house prices.
Westpac economist Dominic Stevens calculates that a 10% CGT would reduce house prices by nearly 11%. It is unclear what effect the RFRM would have, but it should stem the increase.
It might also be worth asking why we should offer a tax preference of zero taxation on nonowner-occupied housing. Although the bright-line and other tests apply to a residential investment property, they are easily circumvented (by holding on to the property for the five years).
Evidence suggests that tax cuts for the rich do not significantly improve the economic performance of a country. In a recent study by the London School of Economics of 18 countries (including New Zealand), tax cuts for the wealthy were found to increase their share of income and did nothing to trickle down to boost real GDP per capita or influence the unemployment rate.
In summary, the preference of non-taxation extended to nonowner-occupied residential property increases inequality and does not contribute to the economic growth of New Zealand in a meaningful way. Tax can play an essential role in reducing (or slowing) runaway house prices, encouraging more productive investment and reducing inequality.
Previous governments, in introducing a fair dividend rate on foreign investment funds, were adamant that they were taxing an imputed return, and was not so evil, shockingly reviled, and radio host criticised as capital gains tax. So perhaps even the political obstacle is illusory.
Craig Elliffe, Professor of Tax Law and Policy, University of Auckland.
This article reflects the opinion of the author and not necessarily the views of the University of Auckland.
Used with permission from the New Zealand Herald, Taxing residential properties: Is it time to pull the lever? 5 January, 2021.
Media queries
Miranda Playfair | Media Adviser
Mob 021 063 8393
Email m.playfair@auckland.ac.nz
Agents (816)
Displaying first 40 results-
agent address No. 08 Bambalapitiya Drive Colombo
Western 00400
Sri Lanka- Contact: Channa Indika Fernando
- Phone: +94 (772) 1141-19 extension 0
- Email: education@3wge.com
- Web: http://3wge.com/
-
agent address Costanilla de los Desamparados,10 Madrid
Madrid 28014
Spain- Contact: Laura Del Valle
- Phone: +34 6213-17148 extension 0
- Email: spain@studycapec.com
- Web: http://www.studycapec.com
-
agent address Suite 3 /145 Melbourne Street Access to the building is on the side in Manning Street South Brisbane
Queensland 4101
Australia- Contact: Laura Del Valle
- Phone: +61 4348-79216 extension 0
- Email: australia@studycapec.com
- Web: http://www.studycapec.com/en
-
agent address 31 avenue de l'Opéra Paris
Ile-de-France 75001
France- Contact: Aude PELAMOURGUES
- Phone: +33 (1) 4326-0323 extension 0
- Email: info@etudes-australie.com
- Web: http://www.etudes-australie.com
-
agent address Suite 1406, Tian An Centre 338 Nanjing Road (West) Shanghai
Shanghai 200003
China- Contact: Emmie HUR
- Phone: +86 (21) 6327-8066 extension 0
- Email: admission@aa-intl.com
- Web: http://www.liuyangbao.com
-
agent address Flat 21, Tower 3, Alakad Towers Alsayeda Khadiga Street, Elsefarat Cairo
Cairo 11765
Egypt- Contact: Yasmin Elawamry
- Phone: +20 (12) 2223-1211 extension 0
- Email: egypt@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address Ground Floor, 333 Collins Street Melbourne
Victoria 3000
Australia- Contact: Claire Maatouk
- Phone: +61 (3) 9629-2677 extension 0
- Email: study@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address Office 12, Building #852, Al Olaya Main Street Al Ghadeer District Riyadh
Riyadh Region 11375
Saudi Arabia- Phone: +966 (11) 2106-988 extension 0
- Email: ksa@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address Office N0 26, Floor 7, Iskan Complex Sharhabeel Street Hawalli
Hawalli 30000
Kuwait- Phone: +965 5598-0004
- Email: kuwait@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address Centre Ashkar Dergham, 4st floor Halba
Aakkar 1302
Lebanon- Contact: Maya Jabbour
- Phone: +961 (6) 6949-25 extension 0
- Email: lebanon@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address Number 2-12, Bawabt Alandalus Hai Alandalus Tripoli
Tripoli 22100
Libya- Phone: +218 (92) 2307-021
- Email: libya@studyco.com
- Web: https://studyco.com/en
-
agent address Immeuble 541 N4 Prestigia, Ville Verte Casablanca
Casablanca-Settat 20320
Morocco- Contact: Kaoutar Fal
- Phone: +212 (600) 1155-00 extension 0
- Email: morocco@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address Office 303, Burlington Tower Al Abraj Street, Business Bay Dubai
Dubai NA
United Arab Emirates- Phone: +971 4343-3427 extension 0
- Email: uae@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address 37B GBM Building Qurum Plaza Muscat
Muscat 112
Oman- Contact: Elizabeth Ipe
- Phone: +968 (8) 2457-1210 extension 0
- Email: oman@studyco.com
- Web: https://studyco.com/
-
agent address Unit 4, 7th Floor, Negar Tower, Negar Alley Vanak Square, Valiasr Avenue Tehran
Tehran 1969833111
Iran- Contact: Saeid Alizadeh Hesari
- Phone: +98 (21) 4234-9000 extension 0
- Email: iran@studyco.com
- Web: http://www.studyco.com
-
agent address Room 1501, 15/F, Grand Plaza Office Tower Two 625 Nathan Road Mong Kok
Yau Tsim Mong NA
Hong Kong- Phone: +852 2323-3287
- Email: application@aas.com.hk
- Web: https://aas.com.hk/
-
agent address Room 302, 3/F, On Hong Commercial Building 145 Hennessy Road Wan Chai
Wan Chai NA
Hong Kong- Phone: +852 2570-5177
- Email: application@aas.com.hk
- Web: https://aas.com.hk/
-
agent address Room E-65, 5/F, 5th Floor, Hin Lei Commercial Centre 16F Rua de São Domingos Macau
Macau N/A
Macao- Phone: +853 2838-9074
- Email: enquiry@aas.com.mo
- Web: http://aas.com.mo/
-
agent address Shop 5 / 466 Boundary Street Spring Hill
Queensland 4000
Australia- Contact: Will Kwong
- Phone: +61 (7) 3839-2938
- Email: enquiry@aaseducation.com.au
- Web: http://aaseducation.com.au/contact-us
-
agent address Office 306 - Level 3/430 Little Collins Street Melbourne
Victoria 3000
Australia- Phone: +61 (3) 9935-5291
- Email: melbourne@australiancentre.com
- Web: http://www.australiancentre.com.br
-
agent address Office 194, Level 1 / 471 Hay street Perth
Western Australia 6000
Australia- Phone: +61 (8) 9321-2444 extension 0
- Email: perth@australiancentre.com
- Web: http://www.australiancentre.com.br
-
agent address Suite 1604, Level 16/447 Kent Street Sydney
New South Wales 2000
Australia- Phone: +61 (2) 9267-5811
- Email: sydney@australiancentre.com
- Web: http://www.australiancentre.com.br
-
agent address Calle 74 # 15 - 80 workshop 617 Bogota
Bogota D.C. 110221
Colombia- Contact: Eduardo Garcia
- Phone: +57 (1) 7035-268 extension 0
- Email: colombia@australiancentre.com
- Web: http://australiancentre.com
-
agent address Room 913, Lippo Sun Plaza 28 Canton Road Tsim Sha Tsui
Kowloon City NA
Hong Kong- Contact: Vanessa Cheng
- Phone: +852 2311-2689 extension 0
- Email: enquiries@ace-hk.org
- Web: http://www.ace-hk.org
-
agent address Level 12, 19 Victoria Street West Auckland Central
Auckland 1010
New Zealand- Phone: +64 (9) 3681-231
- Email: academic.nz@aezyedu.com
-
agent address Level 1, 142, Bauddhaloka Mawatha Colombo
Western 004
Sri Lanka- Contact: Tanika Perera
- Phone: +94 (112) 5563-7 extension 0
- Email: info@adventuseducation.com
- Web: https://adventus.io/
-
agent address Ground Floor, Brisbane Club Tower 241 Adelaide Street Brisbane
Queensland 4000
Australia- Contact: Sonu Agrawal
- Phone: +61 (7) 3158-2808
- Email: info.brisbane@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address Ground Floor, 20 Queen Street Melbourne
Victoria 3000
Australia- Contact: Sonu Agrawal
- Phone: +61 (3) 9614-5900 extension 96145900
- Email: info@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address Level 14, Suite 03 99 Bathurst Street Sydney
New South Wales 2000
Australia- Contact: Sonu Agrawal
- Phone: +61 (2) 9283-5900
- Email: Info.syd@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address 319,17th Floor,Chamchuri Square Building (Office Tower) Phayathai Road Pathum Wan
Bangkok 10330
Thailand- Contact: Kakanang Kittikovit
- Phone: +66 2043-1500 extension 0
- Email: enquiry.th@aeccglobal.com
- Web: https://www.aeccglobal.in
-
agent address Ground Floor, Sina 14 & Acadimias corner Athens
Attica 10672
Greece- Contact: Anastasia Bousios
- Phone: +30 (216) 8002-893
- Email: applications@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address Agias Sofias 32, 1st Floor Thessaloniki
Central Macedonia 54622
Greece- Contact: Anastasia Bousios
- Phone: +30 (216) 8002-894
- Email: info.thess@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address Uni t No. 102, 302 & 403, Mahalya Complex Near Swastik Char Rasta, Off C.G. Road, Navrangpura Ahmedabad
Gujarat 380009
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (79) 4014-1919
- Email: info.amd@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address 2nd Floor, 408, 4th Cross, CMR Road HRBR Layout, 2nd Block, Kalyan Nagar Bengaluru
Karnataka 560043
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (80) 2507-0500
- Email: joel.noronho@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address 1st Floor, SCO 36, 37, 38 Sector 8C, Madhya Marg Chandigarh
Chandigarh 160018
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (172) 4993-333
- Email: info.chd@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address New Door No 49/1-49/7 ,2nd Floor BBCL Magnum College Road Nungambakkam Chennai
Tamil Nadu 600006
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (44) 4016-4545
- Email: info/chn@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address 61/752, First Floor, Chakiat Chambers M.G. Road, Ravipuram Cochin
Kerala 682016
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (484) 4365-555
- Email: Manju.asok@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address Plot No. 15, 2nd Floor Near EPF Office, Sector – 44 Gurgaon
Haryana 122003
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (124) 4886-555
- Email: info.ggn@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address 6-3-1090/1 3rd Floor, Uma Hyderabad House Raj Bhavan Road, Somajiguda Hyderabad
Telangana 500082
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (40) 4252-9999
- Email: info.hyd@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com
-
agent address SCO - 36, Ground Floor PUDA Complex Jalandhar
Punjab 141001
India- Contact: Ankur Agarwal
- Phone: +91 (181) 4035-555
- Email: info.jal@aeccglobal.com
- Web: http://www.aeccglobal.com