What distinguishes human creativity when AI can write, paint and compose?

Copyright law must recognise what makes human creativity uniquely valuable, says Dr Joshua Yuvaraj.

Getty 1600

In an age when AI can be prompted to produce pop music, prose, and portraits, what exactly makes human creativity uniquely valuable?

This is the question at the core of a forthcoming article in the journal Legalities, by Auckland Law School copyright scholar Dr Joshua Yuvaraj.

As governments grapple with the implications of artificial intelligence, the University of Auckland academic and co-director of the New Zealand Centre for Intellectual Property argues that copyright law must better recognise and protect the distinct value of human creativity.

“Copyright offices and courts worldwide seem adamant that copyright protection should only extend to works of human creativity.

“Clearly, this suggests society values something specific about human creativity, but what?”

Dr Joshua Yuvaraj (Auckland Law School)
Dr Joshua Yuvaraj (Auckland Law School)

Yuvaraj identifies three defining features of human creativity: emotions, morality and community. Drawing on decades of creativity research from psychology, neuroscience and other disciplines, he says these features provide a basis for rethinking copyright law in light of AI.

“Emotions connect people to each other on a deeper level; moral thinking matters to ensure what we create is good for the world; and community matters ever more in a fragmented, lonely age.”

Understanding human creativity’s distinct value, says Yuvaraj, is important as governments wrestle with questions about who should own AI-generated works, whether AI companies can use copyrighted material to train their systems and how artists should be compensated.

For now, he says the pattern recognition-based ‘cognitive’ processes of AI models remain different from human cognitive processes: “The models don’t have personal experiences, emotions, or a sense of self to guide moral decisions.”

Protecting human creativity

Yuvaraj argues copyright protection should apply only when there's genuine creative input from a person.

This doesn't necessarily exclude works produced with AI assistance, though. Where a person contributes genuine skill and labour, including through instructions given to an AI system, copyright protection may still be justified.

The degree of human contribution would need to be assessed case by case, he says.

His paper also explores two other directions for copyright reform: strengthening creators' ‘moral rights’ and improving public access to creative works.

Moral rights protect the personal connection between creators and their work, rather than simply its economic value.

Yuvaraj says one possibility would be to give creators a moral right to object when their work is used to train AI. Unlike an economic right that can be sold, this would recognise and protect the emotional connection artists have to their work.

He points to an example from Australia, where a film director recently sued his production company for breaching his moral right of authorship, because he wasn’t clearly acknowledged as the ‘principal director’ of a popular documentary.

He also suggests compensation for the use of copyrighted works in AI training may be necessary to ensure human creativity remains valued.

Making creativity more accessible

Yuvaraj's second proposal focuses on improving public access to creative works, reflecting the importance of community in human creativity.

Artists, writers and musicians rarely create in isolation. They draw on existing works, cultural traditions and the contributions of others, while communities help evaluate, share and develop creative work.

Copyright law, he argues, should therefore make creative works more accessible while preserving creators' economic rights.

Possible approaches include a greater focus on open-access publishing, compulsory licensing (e.g. paying a license to a state authority to use works without the owner’s authorisation, like playing a song in a bar) and exceptions that allow certain uses of copyrighted material without permission.

Yuvaraj also suggests lawmakers could consider whether communal rights might better recognise the collective nature of creativity in Indigenous and First Nations communities.

"These suggestions are just a starting point,” he says. “My paper aims to offer a vision for why policymakers should work to create environments for human creativity to flourish in an increasingly automated age. Human creativity is distinctly valuable because it’s grounded in emotions, morality and community."

The paper forms part of Yuvaraj's wider research into the relationship between copyright law and artistic creativity, which he’s developing into a forthcoming book, The Copyright-Creativity Paradox: Losing Copyright, Reclaiming Artistic Creativity, commissioned by Bristol University Press. To learn more, visit The Creativity Project.

Media contact:

Sophie Boladeras, media adviser
M: 022 4600 388
E: sophie.boladeras@auckland.ac.nz